Skip to content
BestStorefrontThe technology behind better commerce.
Stripe logoSquare logo

Decision desk

Stripe vs Square

Online-first payments infrastructure and a payments + POS provider, compared on channel orientation, rate structure, and online API context—without a universal winner.

Quick answer

How much you sell in person decides it. Choose Stripe if you sell mainly online and need a custom checkout, at 2.9% + 30¢ for a standard US domestic card with no monthly fee; choose Square if you also sell in person and want POS and payments from one provider. On a $10,000 month split 60% online and 40% in person, processing comes to $322 on Stripe and $350 on Square Free; Square Plus matches Stripe’s $322 but adds its $49 monthly fee (editorial calculation below, rates checked Oct 19, 2026).

For each product’s fit and research limitations, read Stripe review and Square review.

On this page

At a glance

Decision factorStripeSquare
OrientationOnline payments / APIsPayments + POS, omnichannel
Online card rate2.9% + 30¢ (standard US domestic card)3.3% + 30¢ on Free; 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus and Premium
API rate2.9% + 30¢ (standard)Online API 2.9% + 30¢ on every plan
In-person card rateTerminal 2.7% + 5¢ (domestic cards), plus reader hardware2.6%, 2.5% or 2.4% + 15¢ by plan, plus hardware
Monthly feeNone on standard pricing$0, $49 or $149 per location
First question to askHow custom is your online checkout?How much do you sell in person?

Architecture and target user

Stripe

Online, API-oriented payments platform.

Worth investigating for online-first businesses and custom checkouts.

Square

Payments plus point-of-sale and omnichannel commerce tools.

Worth investigating for merchants that sell in person and online and want one provider.

Ease and implementation considerations

01

Stripe

Integrate through a storefront plugin or directly via APIs.

02

Square

Choose a Square plan/service—its own online tools or the Online API—plus POS hardware if selling in person.

Research observations from vendor documentation, not usability tests.

Ecosystem and integrations

Stripe

Widely offered by ecommerce platforms; API-first for custom builds.

Square

Used as a standalone commerce system or as a payment provider connected to other storefronts.

Pricing approach

Stripe: Standard US domestic online card: 2.9% + 30¢, with surcharges for manual entry (+0.5%), international cards (+1.5%), and currency conversion (+1%). In person, Stripe Terminal lists 2.7% + 5¢ for domestic cards, +1.5% for international cards and +$0.10 per Tap to Pay authorization; the Stripe Reader M2 is $59. No setup or monthly fees on standard pricing. Checked Oct 19, 2026.

Current Stripe pricing

Square: The plan sets the rate. Square Free is $0 a month, Square Plus $49 and Square Premium $149, each per location. Online card payments (Square’s online tools and invoices) are 3.3% + 30¢ on Free and 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus and Premium; in-person tap, dip or swipe is 2.6% + 15¢, 2.5% + 15¢ and 2.4% + 15¢. The Online API is 2.9% + 30¢ and manual entry or card on file 3.5% + 15¢ on every plan, and cards issued outside the US add 1.5%. Checked Oct 19, 2026.

Current Square pricing

Square’s rate depends on the plan, and both providers price online and in-person payments differently, so a single-number comparison would mislead. The worked example below applies each published rate to the same channel mix.

Worked example

Monthly cost at $10,000 and $50,000 (editorial calculation)

Assumptions: a US business with one location selling 60% online and 40% in person, a $50 average sale in both channels, and only US-issued cards with no manual entry. That is 120 online and 80 in-person payments at $10,000 a month, and 600 and 400 at $50,000. Stripe’s in-person line uses Stripe Terminal’s domestic card rate with a card reader (no Tap to Pay fee); Square’s online line uses each plan’s Online rate. Excludes hardware, refunds, disputes, international cards, custom pricing and any storefront-platform fees. Rates checked on stripe.com/pricing and squareup.com/us/en/pricing on Oct 19, 2026.

Provider and planRates used (online / in person)$10,000 month$50,000 month
Stripe (no monthly fee)2.9% + 30¢ / 2.7% + 5¢$210 + $112 = $322 (3.22%)$1,050 + $560 = $1,610 (3.22%)
Square Free ($0 a month)3.3% + 30¢ / 2.6% + 15¢$234 + $116 = $350 (3.50%)$1,170 + $580 = $1,750 (3.50%)
Square Plus ($49 a month)2.9% + 30¢ / 2.5% + 15¢$210 + $112 + $49 = $371 (3.71%)$1,050 + $560 + $49 = $1,659 (3.32%)
Square Premium ($149 a month)2.9% + 30¢ / 2.4% + 15¢$210 + $108 + $149 = $467 (4.67%)$1,050 + $540 + $149 = $1,739 (3.48%)

Each line is sales × rate + payments × fixed fee. At $10,000: Stripe online $6,000 × 2.9% + 120 × $0.30 = $174 + $36 = $210; Stripe in person $4,000 × 2.7% + 80 × $0.05 = $108 + $4 = $112. Square Free online $6,000 × 3.3% + $36 = $198 + $36 = $234; in person $4,000 × 2.6% + 80 × $0.15 = $104 + $12 = $116. Plus in person $4,000 × 2.5% + $12 = $112; Premium $4,000 × 2.4% + $12 = $108. At $50,000 every processing figure is five times the $10,000 figure; plan fees stay flat. Effective rate = total ÷ monthly sales.

What flips it. Against Square Free, Square Plus saves 0.4% on online sales and 0.1% in person, so on this 60/40 mix it covers its $49 fee at about $17,500 a month ($49 ÷ 0.28%). Premium saves 0.4% online and 0.2% in person, covering $149 at about $46,600 ($149 ÷ 0.32%). An online-only store on Plus or Premium pays the same 2.9% + 30¢ as Stripe, so those plan fees buy POS and other features, not a lower online rate; this calculation ignores feature differences.

Other inputs to check. Stripe’s Tap to Pay adds $0.10 per authorization, or $8 on 80 in-person payments. Cards issued outside the US add 1.5% on both providers. Square invites businesses processing over $250,000 a year to ask about custom pricing, which a $50,000 month ($600,000 a year) exceeds; Stripe offers custom packages for large volume. To rerun the numbers on your own mix, use the payment fee calculator. Hardware is extra on both: the Stripe Reader M2 is $59, and Square lists hardware options starting at $59.

Which businesses each one fits

Choose Stripe if…

  • You sell primarily online.
  • You need custom checkout or payment flows.
  • In-person selling is minor or handled elsewhere.

Choose Square if…

  • You sell in person as well as online.
  • You want POS and online payments from one provider.
  • You are comfortable choosing a Square plan to determine your rate.

Buyer checklist

What to check in a side-by-side trial

  • Run the same online test orders through Stripe and Square’s Online API and reconcile fees.
  • Test an in-person sale on Square alongside online orders and compare unified reporting.
  • Evaluate refunds, disputes, and payout timing for each.

BestStorefront does not name a winner. Run these checks against your own catalog and volumes.

Decision support

Frequently asked questions

Is Square’s online rate the same as Stripe’s?

On some plans. Square’s Online API is 2.9% + 30¢ on every plan, and its Online rate is 2.9% + 30¢ on Square Plus and Premium, matching Stripe’s standard US domestic card rate. Square Free’s Online rate is 3.3% + 30¢, which is $3.60 on a $100 order against $3.20 on Stripe (checked Oct 19, 2026).

Which is better for in-person sales?

It depends on your plan and setup; we have not tested either for in-person workflows. Square is built around POS and lists 2.6% + 15¢ (Free), 2.5% + 15¢ (Plus) or 2.4% + 15¢ (Premium) for tap, dip or swipe. Stripe Terminal lists 2.7% + 5¢ for domestic cards and is described for custom checkouts or integration with third-party POS systems. On a $25 sale that is 80¢ on Square Free and about 73¢ on Stripe Terminal (checked Oct 19, 2026).

Is Stripe or Square cheaper for a business that sells online and in person?

It depends on your mix, average sale and Square plan. In our editorial calculation (60% online, 40% in person, $50 average sale, US cards), a $10,000 month costs $322 on Stripe, $350 on Square Free, $371 on Square Plus including its $49 fee and $467 on Premium including $149. At $50,000 the figures are $1,610, $1,750, $1,659 and $1,739. Rates checked Oct 19, 2026.

When does Square Plus pay for itself?

On processing fees alone, when its savings exceed $49 a month per location. Plus cuts Square’s online rate from 3.3% to 2.9% and its in-person rate from 2.6% to 2.5%. An all-online business breaks even at $12,250 a month in online sales ($49 ÷ 0.4%), an all-in-person one at $49,000 ($49 ÷ 0.1%), and a 60/40 online and in-person mix at about $17,500. Plus also adds POS features, which this does not value.

Do Stripe or Square charge monthly fees?

Stripe’s standard pricing lists no setup or monthly fees. Square Free is $0 a month; Square Plus is $49 and Square Premium $149 a month, each per location, so two locations on Plus cost $98 a month. Hardware is extra on both: the Stripe Reader M2 is $59 and Square lists hardware from $59 (checked Oct 19, 2026).

How do international cards change Stripe and Square fees?

Both add a surcharge. Stripe adds 1.5% for international cards online and in person, plus 1% online if currency conversion is required; Square adds 1.5% for cards issued outside the US. On a $100 online order that is $4.70 on Stripe (or $5.70 with conversion), $4.70 on Square Plus or Premium and $5.10 on Square Free (editorial calculation from rates checked Oct 19, 2026).

What changed
  • Oct 19, 2026: Re-checked Stripe and Square rates; added Square’s per-plan online and in-person rates and plan fees, Stripe Terminal’s in-person rate, a worked monthly cost at $10,000 and $50,000, and four FAQs.