Quick answer
This page is for a US Shopify store billing in USD that is adding subscriptions or reconsidering its subscription app. The arithmetic assumes $10,000 or $50,000 a month in subscription revenue from $40 orders, one order per subscriber per month (250 or 1,250 orders).
Start with Shopify's free Shopify Subscriptions app if you need simple subscribe-and-save and don't need bundles. Move to a flat-fee app such as Appstle ($30/month at $10,000 in subscription revenue, 0% transaction fee) when you need more control. Consider Recharge when subscriptions are a large share of revenue and you want its retention, bundle and migration tooling, and can absorb its per-transaction fees. On published fees alone, the flat-fee apps cost less than any paid percentage plan at every revenue level we checked: at $10,000 a month, $119.40 a year on Seal and $360 on Appstle, against $1,799.88 to $8,988 on the percentage apps. Prices were re-checked on each vendor's own page or Shopify App Store listing on Oct 31, 2026; none of these apps has been tested hands-on, and none is ranked.
On this page
Buyer and scenarios
Who this page is for
A Shopify store in the US, paying app fees in USD, at roughly $10,000 to $50,000 a month in subscription revenue. The four situations below change which costs and features matter; the decision table later on this page maps each one to a starting point.
Adding subscribe-and-save
A store selling mostly one-time orders adds a subscribe option to a few products people reorder. Subscriptions stay a small share of revenue, so app cost and a simple setup matter more than retention tooling. Start with the free plans and the Shopify Subscriptions decision table.
Subscription-first replenishment brand
Most revenue renews on a schedule, such as coffee, supplements or pet food. At $50,000 a month the fee gap between apps passes $1,300 a month, so the annual totals and the retention break-even decide more than the feature list.
Box or curation business
Customers receive, or build, a box of several products. Shopify says bundles aren't compatible with its free app, so the choice is among paid apps that document bundles or build-a-box, or a standalone platform such as Subbly.
Store migrating an existing program
Active subscribers, stored payment methods and next charge dates already exist. Shopify's import rules, who moves payment tokens and each vendor's migration offer matter as much as the new fee.
Criteria
What we compared and where coverage stops
The seven Shopify apps publish their prices on their own pages or Shopify App Store listings, and together they cover the three ways these apps charge: free, flat tiers, and a monthly fee plus a percentage. Subbly appears only as a contrast, because it is a standalone subscription platform rather than a Shopify app. WooCommerce Subscriptions answers the platform question for stores not on Shopify. The tables below check each app against these eight points wherever the vendor documents them.
Fee base
Check whether a percentage fee applies to subscription orders only, or also to one-time orders, shipping, tax and refunds (Recharge's applies to all of those).
Revenue caps
Flat-fee apps such as Appstle tier by monthly subscription revenue; know what happens in a month you exceed the cap.
Checkout and gateways
Most apps run on Shopify's checkout; Shopify Subscriptions works with five gateways only.
Customer portal
Check which actions customers can take themselves: skip, swap, reschedule, cancel.
Retention tools
Check cancellation flows, failed-payment retries and win-backs, then weigh them against the fee gap with the retention break-even table.
Bundles and build-a-box
Shopify says bundles don't work with its own subscriptions app; paid apps add them on some plans.
Migration
Ask who moves stored payment tokens, which plan includes the vendor's migration help, and how next charge dates carry over.
Contract term
Recharge Plus and Skio's annual price involve longer commitments than month-to-month plans.
Where coverage stops. Prices are US list prices in USD; Subbly notes that VAT may apply in the UK and EU, and other currencies weren't checked. Quoted plans (Recharge Custom, Loop, Skio and Bold Enterprise, Appstle Enterprise Plus) are named but not priced. We didn't source a current BigCommerce subscription option for this update, so BigCommerce isn't covered here. Payment processing, Shopify plan fees, taxes and fulfillment of subscription orders are outside the arithmetic. Where a feature wasn't part of our check, the tables say so rather than guess. App Store ratings aren't used to order anything.
Plans and costs
Free plans, kept separate
| Free option | Limit | At a $40 order | Next paid step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Subscriptions | Free app; no app fee or transaction fee listed | No revenue or subscriber cap listed | A paid app, if you need bundles, build-a-box or prepaid plans |
| Appstle Free | Up to $500 a month in subscription revenue | 12 subscribers ($480 a month) | Starter, $10 a month (to $5,000) |
| Seal Free | 50 total subscriptions, unlimited revenue | $2,000 a month at 50 subscribers | Supersale, $5.95 a month (100 subscriptions) |
| Loop Free Forever | 50 active subscriptions | $2,000 a month at 50 subscribers | Starter, $99 a month + 1.0% |
At the $10,000 scenario (250 subscribers), only Shopify Subscriptions is still free. Shopify plan and payment processing fees apply with every app, and Shopify notes third-party transaction fees when PayPal Express is used without Shopify Payments activated. Loop's free migration applies to paid plans, not Free Forever.
A paid entry plan, not a free one: Recharge's 25-50 plan is $25 a month with no transaction fees. Its help center limits it to stores that installed on or after Feb 9, 2026 and aren't under contract, with 50 or fewer subscription customers over the store's lifetime. Active, inactive and test customers all count, and deleting customers doesn't lower the count. It applies after the 60-day trial, and a store that passes 50 moves to Starter automatically and can't move back.
Billing models
How each paid app bills
| App | Monthly plans (USD) | Yearly billing | Usage fee and what it applies to | Terms, add-ons and Shopify Plus |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appstle Subscriptions | Starter $10 (to $5,000 in subscription revenue), Business $30 (to $15,000), Business Premium $100 (to $100,000), Enterprise $300 (to $500,000), Enterprise Plus by quote | $96, $288, $960 and $2,880 a year ($8, $24, $80 and $240 a month) | 0% transaction fee | 14-day trial; billed every 30 days; what happens in a month above the cap is not published; add-ons from higher plans are available but not priced |
| Seal Subscriptions | Supersale $5.95 (100 subscriptions), Rising Star $9.95 (250), Legend $24.95 (500), Leader $89.95 (2,000), Mega Star $199 (50,000), Superstar $399 (150,000) | 20% off: $57.12, $95.52, $239.52, $863.52, $1,910.40 and $3,830.40 a year ($4.76, $7.96, $19.96, $71.96, $159.20 and $319.20 a month) | 0%; priced by number of subscriptions, not revenue | 30-day trial; custom plans above 150,000 subscriptions on request |
| Bold Subscriptions | Launch $24.99, Grow $49.99, Scale $74.99, Ultimate Retention $399.99 | None published | 2%, 1%, 0.9% and 0.9% of the whole order when it contains a subscription item | 30-day trial on the first three plans, with transaction fees still charged; Ultimate Retention includes 1,000 cancellation sessions a month, then $0.70 each; Enterprise pricing above $1M a year in subscription revenue |
| Loop Subscriptions | Starter $99, Pro $399, Enterprise negotiable | None published; month-to-month | 1.0% (Starter) or 0.75% (Pro) of transaction volume; $0 per order | 14-day trial; no setup, migration or onboarding fees; checkout upgrades need Shopify Plus |
| Recharge | 25-50 $25 (conditions below), Starter $99, Plus $499, Custom by quote | None published | Starter 1.49% + 19¢ and Plus 1.34% + 19¢ on every order Recharge processes, including one-time orders, shipping, taxes and refunded orders | 60-day trial on Starter; 25-50 and Starter month-to-month; Plus and Custom on 12-month terms; Concierge SMS (Plus) +$0.03 a message segment in the US and Canada, +$0.06 elsewhere; Shopify Plus merchants may be eligible for discounted Custom pricing |
| Skio | Scale $599, Enterprise custom | $499 a month billed yearly ($5,988 a year) | 1% + 20¢ on orders involving a subscription | No setup, migration or onboarding fees; Skio Loyalty has a separate fee; no Skio SMS charge, but carrier rates apply; Skio's FAQ is unclear on whether there is a free trial |
From each vendor's pricing page, help center or Shopify App Store listing, checked Oct 31, 2026. No vendor changed a price since our Oct 7 check. Seal's monthly equivalents are our arithmetic on its yearly totals. Bold's pricing overview lists Ultimate Retention at $399.99, while its transaction-fee article says $399.00; the table uses $399.99. Recharge's help center still quotes Starter at 1.25% + 19¢ in one section; its pricing page and App Store listing show 1.49% + 19¢, used here.
Worked example
Annual app cost at two revenue levels
Labeled arithmetic on the list prices above, in USD. Assumptions: a $40 average order that already includes shipping and tax, one order per subscriber per month and no one-time orders or refunds, so $10,000 is 250 orders and $50,000 is 1,250 orders. Payment processing, Shopify plan fees and add-ons such as SMS are excluded. Shopify Subscriptions is $0 in app fees at both levels and sits in the free table above.
| Paid app and plan | $10,000/mo: per month | $10,000/mo: per year | $50,000/mo: per month | $50,000/mo: per year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appstle Business ($30, to $15k) / Business Premium ($100, to $100k) | $30 | 12 × $30 = $360 ($288 billed yearly) | $100 | 12 × $100 = $1,200 ($960 billed yearly) |
| Seal Rising Star ($9.95, 250 subs) / Leader ($89.95, 2,000 subs) | $9.95 | 12 × $9.95 = $119.40 ($95.52 billed yearly) | $89.95 | 12 × $89.95 = $1,079.40 ($863.52 billed yearly) |
| Bold Grow ($49.99 + 1%) / Scale ($74.99 + 0.9%) | $49.99 + $100 = $149.99 | 12 × $149.99 = $1,799.88 | $74.99 + $450 = $524.99 | 12 × $524.99 = $6,299.88 |
| Loop Starter ($99 + 1.0%) | $99 + $100 = $199 | 12 × $199 = $2,388 | $99 + $500 = $599 | 12 × $599 = $7,188 |
| Recharge Starter ($99 + 1.49% + 19¢) | $99 + $149 + $47.50 = $295.50 | 12 × $295.50 = $3,546 | $99 + $745 + $237.50 = $1,081.50 | 12 × $1,081.50 = $12,978 |
| Recharge Plus ($499 + 1.34% + 19¢, 12-month term) | $499 + $134 + $47.50 = $680.50 | 12 × $680.50 = $8,166 | $499 + $670 + $237.50 = $1,406.50 | 12 × $1,406.50 = $16,878 |
| Skio Scale ($599 monthly or $499 billed yearly, + 1% + 20¢) | $599 + $100 + $50 = $749 | 12 × $749 = $8,988 ($7,788 billed yearly) | $599 + $500 + $250 = $1,349 | 12 × $1,349 = $16,188 ($14,988 billed yearly) |
Editorial calculation from each vendor's pricing page or Shopify App Store listing, checked Oct 31, 2026. Seal's $9.95 plan covers exactly 250 subscriptions, so a growing store would need its $24.95 plan. Recharge charges on the full order total, so if your own $40 excludes shipping and tax, its rows are understated. For Recharge against Appstle alone, with the help-center rate worked through, see Recharge vs Appstle.
Break-even
When a flat fee beats percentage pricing
Flat fee against percentage. We ran every revenue level from $501 to $500,000 a month, in $1 steps, at a $40 order. At each one, the Appstle plan that covers that revenue costs less than the cheapest paid Bold, Loop, Recharge or Skio plan, and so does Seal's plan for the matching subscription count. The exception is Loop's free plan: Free Forever is $0 up to 50 active subscriptions ($2,000 a month at $40), the same as Seal Free and $10 less than Appstle Starter. At $5,000 a month, Appstle Starter is $10 against Bold Grow's $49.99 + $50 = $99.99; at $100,000, Appstle Business Premium is $100 against Bold Scale's $74.99 + $900 = $974.99. On published fees alone, the flat fee costs less across that range once a store has more than 50 subscribers.
Plan against plan. Inside one app, a higher plan pays off once the lower percentage saves more than the extra plan fee: crossover = plan fee difference ÷ percentage difference.
| Plans | Difference | Crossover (monthly volume) | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bold Launch to Grow | $25 more a month, 1 percentage point less | $25 ÷ 1% = $2,500 | Grow costs less above $2,500 a month, the same line Bold's own plan guidance draws |
| Bold Grow to Scale | $25 more, 0.1 point less | $25 ÷ 0.1% = $25,000 | Scale costs less above $25,000 a month, again matching Bold's guidance |
| Loop Starter to Pro | $300 more, 0.25 point less | $300 ÷ 0.25% = $120,000 | On fees alone Pro costs more below $120,000 a month; it also adds prepaid and backup-card charging |
| Recharge Starter to Plus | $400 more, 0.15 point less (both add 19¢ an order) | $400 ÷ 0.15% ≈ $266,667 | On fees alone Plus costs more below about $266,667 a month processed; it is a 12-month term with bundles, SMS and migration support |
Fee against results. A percentage app has to earn its extra cost back through revenue its tools keep or add. Revenue needed = fee gap ÷ your gross margin; ÷ $40 gives subscribers. The table uses the $100 flat fee of Appstle Business Premium at $50,000 a month; against Seal Leader ($89.95), each gap is $10.05 larger.
| App at $50,000/mo | Gap over $100 a month | Revenue to cover it at a 50% margin (subscribers) | At a 70% margin (subscribers) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bold Scale ($524.99) | $424.99 | $849.98 (about 21) | $607.13 (about 15) |
| Loop Starter ($599) | $499 | $998 (about 25) | $712.86 (about 18) |
| Recharge Starter ($1,081.50) | $981.50 | $1,963 (about 49) | $1,402.14 (about 35) |
| Recharge Plus ($1,406.50) | $1,306.50 | $2,613 (about 65) | $1,866.43 (about 47) |
| Skio Scale, monthly ($1,349) | $1,249 | $2,498 (about 62) | $1,784.29 (about 45) |
The 50% and 70% margins are illustrations, not benchmarks; use your own. The figures ignore the app's fee on the added revenue, which raises each one slightly. Whether any app's tools reach these numbers is not something we can verify, and recovery rates that vendors publish are their own claims.
Portal, retries, boxes
Operations each app documents
| App | Customer portal | Failed payments and cancellations | Bundles, build-a-box, prepaid | Analytics |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Subscriptions | Customer accounts: resume, skip, pause or cancel; update payment method and shipping address | You set retry attempts, days between them and the action after the last one (skip, pause or cancel), for failed payments and for low inventory | Bundles not compatible; plan settings list no prepaid option (Shopify's help mentions prepaid subscriptions only for draft orders); plans can set a fixed billing day or date and a maximum number of orders | Active, paused and canceled subscriptions |
| Appstle Subscriptions | Shopify native portal on Free; advanced portal from Business | Payment retry on Free; retention tools and cancellation control from Business ($30) | Pay-as-you-go and prepaid on Free; build-a-box and bundling from Business | Included on Free |
| Seal Subscriptions | Customer portal on every plan, per Seal's pricing table | Dunning settings on every plan; cancellation flow on Legend per the pricing page, Rising Star per the App Store listing | Prepaid on every plan; bundles not in our check | Not in our check |
| Bold Subscriptions | Bold says every plan includes every feature; our check didn't itemize them | Ultimate Retention adds ProsperStack cancellation prevention | Not in our check | Not in our check |
| Loop Subscriptions | Mobile portal on Free Forever; multilingual portal on Pro | Dunning with 15 retries and cancellation flows on paid plans; backup-card charging and hard-decline retry control on Pro | Build-your-own and preset bundles on paid plans; prepaid on Pro and Enterprise; gifting on paid plans | Growth and revenue analytics on Free Forever |
| Recharge | No-code portal: add and swap products, reschedule deliveries; passwordless login | Failed-payment recovery with retries, cancellation prevention and win-backs | Prepaid and gift subscriptions; customizable bundles and tiered discounts on Plus | Included |
| WooCommerce Subscriptions (platform) | My Account: suspend, cancel, switch plans and update payment methods | Automatic failed-payment retry, a setting you turn on; manual renewal invoices on any gateway | Renewal date synchronization; bundles not in our check | Subscriptions Health Check; reporting not in our check |
On Shopify Subscriptions, renewals are billed at 10:00 am store time on the day after they're due. Shopify says card auto-updating is widely supported in the US on Shopify Payments, while on other gateways customers may need to update cards themselves. Local, manual and non-card payment methods may not be available for subscriptions.
From each vendor's pricing page, App Store listing or help center, checked Oct 31, 2026. “Not in our check” means the feature wasn't part of what we read, not that the app lacks it. Skio is left out of this table because our check covered its pricing, migration and add-on terms only.
Migration
Moving an existing subscription program
A switch moves three things: subscription contracts (products, prices, schedules and next charge dates), the stored payment methods behind them, and the customer records they belong to. On Shopify, the help center sets these rules:
- Importing into Shopify Subscriptions. Contracts import by CSV, and only from third-party apps that are Shopify Checkout integrated. Each row needs a
customer_payment_method_id, theupcoming_billing_datemust be at least 24 hours after the import, and only Active or Paused contracts import. An import can't edit or overwrite existing contracts (duplicate handles are skipped), and files are capped at 10 MB. Contracts export to another store running Shopify Subscriptions. - Payment tokens. They can be migrated on every Shopify plan, and the subscription app developer does it. Customer records and products must exist in Shopify first.
- Card numbers. Moving full card numbers needs Shopify Plus or Enterprise and Shopify Professional Services, a paid service with no published price. PayPal billing agreements can't be moved through that service.
- Slow-drip option. A secondary gateway (Stripe, Braintree, PayPal Express or Authorize.net) keeps billing existing contracts while new and updated ones move to the primary gateway. Shopify says this can take months or even years, and turning the old gateway off early needs Plus or Enterprise.
Risks Shopify documents. Repeated failed renewals can pause, skip or cancel a contract, depending on retry settings, and a new payment method can't restore a cancelled contract. Before updating a payment method, check for an already scheduled retry so the customer isn't charged twice. Uninstalling Shopify Subscriptions deletes its plans, contracts and discounts, so export before removing it.
| Vendor | Migration offer | Conditions and timing (vendor's own words) |
|---|---|---|
| Loop Subscriptions | White-glove migration of customer details, subscriptions, payment tokens and billing preferences; no setup, migration or onboarding fees | Every paid plan, not Free Forever; sandbox and post-migration support on Enterprise only; Loop says many migrations finish within a few weeks |
| Recharge | End-to-end migration support and hands-on implementation | Plus ($499 a month + 1.34% + 19¢, 12-month term) |
| Appstle Subscriptions | Hands-on migration and app integrations | Listed on the Free plan in Appstle's App Store listing |
| Skio | Migration and onboarding included; no setup, migration or onboarding fees | Skio says most stores are fully migrated in about 4 weeks |
| Bold Subscriptions | Free white-glove migration | Bold says it usually takes less than a day once scheduled; priority migration support on Scale and Ultimate Retention |
| Subbly (standalone) | Free migration, including payment tokens | Moves the program onto Subbly's own store platform, off Shopify |
From each vendor's pricing page, migration page, help center or App Store listing, checked Oct 31, 2026. Seal's migration terms weren't part of our check. Subbly also advertises six months free for stores that switch before Dec 31; its pricing page doesn't show the eligibility terms, so treat it as a time-limited offer, not a price. If you're leaving Recharge specifically, Recharge alternatives covers when staying makes sense.
Fit and skip
Who each app fits, and who should skip it
Not ranked. Listed in the same order as the cost tables, with the scenario letters from the top of the page. Free plans and fee models are in the tables above.
Shopify Subscriptions
Fits: scenario A stores on one of its five gateways that want $0 in app fees, plans managed in Shopify admin and simple schedules, including a fixed billing day or a set number of orders. Skip if: you sell boxes or bundles, need prepaid plans, or need Shopify Scripts discounts or gift cards to apply after the first payment.
Appstle Subscriptions
Fits: scenario A and C stores that want a fee that doesn't grow with each order: free to $500 a month, $30 to $15,000 with build-a-box and bundling, $100 to $100,000. Skip if: you expect to cross a revenue cap and need the overage terms in writing first, since Appstle doesn't publish them.
Seal Subscriptions
Fits: scenario A stores and programs with a high order value, because Seal prices by subscription count rather than revenue: a $100 box and a $20 refill cost the same plan fee. Skip if: you need to know how cancelled subscriptions count toward the limit, or which tier includes the cancellation flow; Seal's sources don't settle either.
Bold Subscriptions
Fits: stores whose carts are almost all subscription items and that want every feature on every plan, plans whose percentage steps down as revenue passes $2,500 and $25,000 a month, and free white-glove migration. Skip if: many carts mix one-time and subscription items, since the fee covers the whole order, or you want a trial without transaction fees.
Loop Subscriptions
Fits: scenario B and C brands that want percentage pricing with no per-order fee, month-to-month terms, build-a-box and 15 dunning retries from Starter, and migration included on every paid plan. Skip if: you need prepaid below Pro ($399 + 0.75%), a sandbox or post-migration support below Enterprise, or checkout upgrades without Shopify Plus.
Recharge
Fits: scenario B brands that will use cancellation prevention, failed-payment recovery and win-backs; scenario D stores that want end-to-end migration support on Plus; and new installs that qualify for the $25 25-50 plan. Skip if: your margins can't carry 1.49% + 19¢ on full order totals including one-time orders, or you can't commit to Plus's 12-month term for bundles and SMS.
Skio
Fits: larger scenario B brands that want migration and onboarding included at no fee (Skio estimates about 4 weeks) and can commit to $499 a month billed yearly. Skip if: you're leaving Recharge for a different company, since Recharge announced its acquisition of Skio on Apr 27, 2026; or you're near $10,000 a month, where Skio's $599 base fee alone is more than the full monthly cost of Appstle, Seal, Bold, Loop or Recharge Starter.
Subbly
Fits: scenario C box businesses ready to run the whole store on a subscription-first platform: Subbly $69 a month or $621 a year, Max $149 or $1,341, plus 1% + 12¢ on Stripe (1.25% on other gateways), with free migration including payment tokens. Skip if: you're staying on Shopify; Subbly replaces the store platform rather than adding an app to it.
WooCommerce Subscriptions
Fits: WooCommerce stores: $279 a year ($23.25 a month billed annually) or $446.40 for two years, a 30-day money-back guarantee, 25+ gateways for automatic renewals, and suspend, cancel and plan switching in My Account. Skip if: you're on Shopify, where the free app already covers the basics.
Skio and Recharge. Recharge announced on Apr 27, 2026 that Skio had joined it, and Skio's App Store listing is now titled “Skio, a Recharge Company”. Recharge says both platforms continue to operate. Our Oct 7 version of this page missed that.
Limitations
Limitations and open questions
- Shopify Subscriptions: five gateways only (Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen for stores with existing Adyen approval, and Stripe for select merchants); bundles aren't compatible; Shopify Scripts discounts and gift cards apply to the first payment only.
- Appstle: every plan has a revenue cap, and what happens in a month above it isn't published on the pricing page, App Store listing or FAQ. Enterprise and its $2,880 yearly price appear only on Appstle's own pricing page.
- Seal: limits count “total subscriptions”, and Seal doesn't say whether cancelled ones count. Its listing and pricing page place the cancellation flow on different tiers.
- Bold: the fee covers the whole order once it contains a subscription item, transaction fees are charged during the trial, and Ultimate Retention has no trial and two published prices ($399.99 and $399.00).
- Loop: prepaid starts on Pro, checkout upgrades need Shopify Plus, and Free Forever appears in the pricing-page FAQ and on the App Store listing rather than as a pricing card.
- Recharge: the fee base includes one-time orders, shipping, taxes and refunded orders; the 25-50 plan is one-way; one help-center section still quotes the older 1.25% Starter rate.
- Skio: Recharge announced its acquisition on Apr 27, 2026; its FAQ contradicts itself on a free trial; Skio Loyalty's price isn't published.
Decision framework
Shopify Subscriptions or a paid app?
| Scenario | Shopify Subscriptions is enough when | Look at a paid app when | Arithmetic to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Adding subscribe-and-save | You use one of its five gateways, sell single products on simple schedules and don't need prepaid | You need prepaid or bundles: Appstle Free includes prepaid up to $500 a month; Seal's free plan covers 50 subscriptions | At $10,000: Seal $9.95 or Appstle $30 a month, against $149.99 to $749 on the percentage apps |
| B. Subscription-first replenishment | Its retries, customer-account portal and analytics cover what you'd use | You'd use cancellation offers, win-backs or backup-card charging; check the retention break-even before choosing a percentage app | Fee gap ÷ your gross margin (retention break-even table) |
| C. Box or curation | Not a fit: Shopify says bundles aren't compatible | Appstle Business and Loop's paid plans list build-a-box; Recharge lists customizable bundles on Plus; Subbly if you'd leave Shopify | At $10,000: Appstle Business $30, Loop Starter $199, Recharge Plus $680.50 a month |
| D. Migrating a program | Your current app is Shopify Checkout integrated, so contracts can be imported by CSV, and payment tokens can move without card numbers | You want the vendor to run the move: Loop (paid plans), Recharge (Plus), Appstle (listed on Free), Skio or Bold | Switch checklist below; Shopify Plus or Enterprise if card numbers must move |
Next step
Work out your own fee, then switch safely
Fee formula. Monthly app cost = plan fee + (percentage × fee base) + (per-order fee × orders). Annual cost = 12 × the monthly cost, or the yearly price where one exists (Appstle, Seal and Skio). Use each app's own fee base from the billing table: Recharge counts one-time orders, shipping, tax and refunds; Bold counts the whole order; Skio counts orders involving a subscription. For example, $20,000 a month in $50 orders (400 orders) on Recharge Starter is $99 + (1.49% × $20,000 = $298) + (19¢ × 400 = $76) = $473 a month, or $5,676 a year.
Switch checklist. Before you change apps:
- Export first. Save every contract with its next charge date, and don't uninstall Shopify Subscriptions before exporting.
- Check the import path. Confirm whether your current app is Shopify Checkout integrated, which Shopify requires for a CSV import into Shopify Subscriptions.
- Ask who moves payment tokens and whether any card numbers need Shopify Plus or Enterprise and Professional Services.
- Check your gateway. If it's Stripe, Braintree, PayPal Express or Authorize.net, ask whether the old gateway will stay on as a secondary gateway and for how long.
- Avoid double charges. Set the first billing date in the new app at least 24 hours after import, switch billing off in the old app for the same contracts, and check for scheduled retries before updating a payment method.
- Get the migration offer in writing: which plan includes it, what it costs and how long the vendor expects it to take.
- Recalculate the fee with the formula above at your real order mix, including one-time orders, shipping and tax where the fee base counts them.
- Check the term: Recharge Plus and Custom run 12 months, and Skio's lower price is billed yearly.
Read more
Our overviews and comparisons
- Recharge: platform fee plus transaction fees; broad retention toolkit; $25/month for new stores with up to 50 subscribers.
- Appstle Subscriptions: free to $500/month in subscription revenue, then flat plans from $10.
- Shopify Subscriptions: free, managed in Shopify admin, with documented limits on bundles and gateways.
- Subbly: a standalone subscription commerce platform rather than a Shopify app.
- Recharge vs Appstle: the two fee models side by side at $10,000 and $50,000 a month.
- Recharge alternatives: six apps compared with Recharge, and when staying on it makes sense.
- Shopify vs WooCommerce: total cost at three store sizes, including what subscriptions add on each platform.
Decision support
Frequently asked questions
Which Shopify subscription app should I start with?
It depends on revenue and needs. Shopify Subscriptions is free for basic subscribe-and-save, Appstle offers flat pricing with no transaction fee, and Recharge suits brands that want broader retention tooling and can absorb percentage fees.
How much does Recharge cost?
Starter is $99/month plus 1.49% + 19¢ per transaction, and Plus is $499/month plus 1.34% + 19¢ on a 12-month term. The 25-50 plan is $25/month with no transaction fees for stores that installed on or after Feb 9, 2026 and have had 50 or fewer subscription customers in total; active, inactive and test customers count, and the store moves to Starter for good after that. Checked Oct 31, 2026.
Is Shopify Subscriptions free?
Yes. The app has no charge; your Shopify plan and payment processing fees still apply. Shopify's help center says bundles aren't compatible with it.
How do I move subscriptions to a different Shopify subscription app?
Export your contracts and next charge dates first. On Shopify, payment tokens can be migrated on every plan and the subscription app developer does it; moving full card numbers needs Shopify Plus or Enterprise and Shopify's paid Professional Services. Shopify Subscriptions imports contracts by CSV only from apps that are Shopify Checkout integrated, with a next billing date at least 24 hours after the import. Loop includes migration on its paid plans, Recharge on Plus, and Appstle lists hands-on migration on its free plan. Checked Oct 31, 2026.
What do subscription app percentage fees apply to?
It differs by app. Recharge charges on every order it processes, including one-time orders, shipping, taxes and refunded orders. Bold charges on the whole order when it contains a subscription item. Skio charges 1% + 20¢ on orders involving a subscription. Loop charges a percentage of transaction volume with no per-order fee. Appstle and Seal charge no transaction fee. Payment processing is separate with every app.
What will a subscription app cost at my revenue?
Add the plan fee, the percentage times the fee base and the per-order fee times your orders, then multiply by 12 or use the yearly price. At $10,000 a month in $40 orders (250 orders), the paid apps cost $30 (Appstle), $9.95 (Seal), $149.99 (Bold), $199 (Loop), $295.50 (Recharge Starter), $680.50 (Recharge Plus) and $749 (Skio) a month. At $50,000 (1,250 orders) they cost $100, $89.95, $524.99, $599, $1,081.50, $1,406.50 and $1,349. Shopify Subscriptions has no app fee.
Is Skio owned by Recharge?
Yes. Recharge announced on Apr 27, 2026 that Skio had joined Recharge, and Skio's Shopify App Store listing is titled 'Skio, a Recharge Company'. Recharge says both platforms continue to operate.
Have you tested these apps?
No. These are independent editorial overviews based on first-party pricing pages and help centers, not hands-on testing.
Documentation
Sources (checked Oct 31, 2026)
What changed
- Oct 31, 2026: Re-checked every price and term on vendor pages; no vendor changed a price since Oct 7. Added the buyer and four scenarios, free plans in their own table, how each paid app bills, annual totals, break-even arithmetic, an operations table, Shopify's migration rules and vendor migration offers, fit and skip lines for seven apps plus Subbly and WooCommerce Subscriptions, limitations, a decision table, a fee formula and switch checklist, and four FAQs. Corrected an omission: Recharge announced its acquisition of Skio on Apr 27, 2026.
- Oct 7, 2026: Published with eight subscription apps compared by monthly cost at $10,000 and $50,000 in subscription revenue.