Skip to content
BestStorefrontThe technology behind better commerce.
Rebuy logoRokt Aftersell logo

Decision desk

Rebuy vs Rokt Aftersell

Two Shopify conversion products compared on breadth, upsell surfaces, Shopify Plus requirements and monthly cost from 500 to 10,000 orders. They overlap but are not direct substitutes in every workflow, and no winner is declared.

Quick answer

Choose Rebuy if you need cart, search or merchandising personalization, from $25/month for one package up to 500 orders ($225 for post-purchase at 5,000); choose Aftersell if post-purchase offers are the main job, from $34.99/month up to 500 orders and $259.99 at 5,000. Aftersell's Shopify App Store listing is live (checked Nov 1, 2026); it was unavailable when we checked on Oct 13 and Oct 19, 2026.

For each product’s fit and research limitations, read Rebuy review and Rokt Aftersell review.

On this page

At a glance

Decision factorRebuyRokt Aftersell
Direct substitutes?Not always; broader personalizationNot always; focused upsell application
Primary scopeCart, checkout, post-purchase, search, merchandising, testingProduct/cart, checkout, post-purchase, thank-you upsells
PlatformShopify, Shopify Plus, HydrogenShopify; App Store listing live (checked Nov 1, 2026)
Pricing basisOrders/month per package; 10–30% bundle discountsStarting price + per-order fee above 500 orders, with a monthly cap
Published entry price$25/month for one package (up to 500 orders)$34.99/month Post-Purchase (up to 500 orders)
Post-purchase price at 5,000 orders$225/month (Checkout & Post-Purchase)$259.99/month (Post-Purchase)
Published price ceilingNone; sales quote above 7,500 orders$599.99 to $1,359.99 a month by plan; sales quote from 20,000 orders
Shopify Plus needed forCheckout Extensions and Landing PagesCheckout upsells
Free trial14 days per package30 days per plan
A/B testing featuresFlows & A/B Testing package; method not on its pricing pageA/B tests on Pre-Purchase; multivariate testing with real-time analytics on Post-Purchase; method not on its pricing page

Architecture and target user

Rebuy

A Shopify personalization platform spanning cart, checkout, post-purchase, search, merchandising, flows, and A/B testing packages.

Worth investigating for Shopify teams considering a broader personalization layer across multiple shopping surfaces.

Rokt Aftersell

A Shopify app focused on one-click post-purchase offers, checkout and thank-you-page upsells, plus product and cart upsells.

Worth investigating when the immediate job is focused upselling across Shopify purchase surfaces.

Ease and implementation considerations

01

Rebuy

Rebuy's pricing page marks Checkout Extensions as Shopify Plus exclusive, and its help center says they need both Plus and the Checkout & Post-Purchase package; Landing Pages are also Plus-only. No Plus requirement is listed for Post-Purchase Offers. Theme and page-speed guidance are not on the pricing page (checked Oct 19, 2026).

02

Rokt Aftersell

Aftersell marks checkout upsells as Shopify Plus only and includes them in the Post-Purchase and Complete plans (checked Oct 19, 2026). The app installs from its Shopify App Store listing, which showed an Install button when re-checked Nov 1, 2026.

Research observations from vendor documentation, not usability tests.

Ecosystem and integrations

Rebuy

Shopify-specific: the pricing page lists Shopify, Shopify Plus and Hydrogen, and names Klaviyo, Yotpo, Recharge, Tapcart, Okendo, Builder and Attentive in its app marketplace. Its developer docs cover a REST API for recommendation data sources, widgets and analytics events; multi-store and export terms are not described (checked Oct 19, 2026).

Rokt Aftersell

Shopify-specific. The Shopify App Store lists Rokt as developer, and the pricing page footer names Aftersell as a registered trademark of Rokt, Inc. Rokt Thanks is described as SOC 2, ISO 27001, GDPR and CCPA compliant; app and analytics connections are not listed on the pricing page (checked Oct 19, 2026).

Pricing approach

Rebuy: Build-your-own starts at $25/month. Each package has a flat price up to 500 orders a month (Cart & Merchandising $45, Checkout & Post-Purchase $25, Search & Collections $35, Flows & A/B Testing $35) and a higher one above that: Checkout & Post-Purchase is $49 at 1,000 orders and $225 at 5,000. Bundles take 10%, 20% or 30% off two, three or four packages; annual billing saves 10%; each package has a 14-day free trial. The calculator prices up to 7,500 orders and shows "Talk to sales" above that. Platform One (all four packages, Premium Support, beta product access and a dedicated CSM): the page HTML carries a $534/month billed-monthly card with no order count, but in a browser that card is hidden and Platform One goes through Rebuy's solutions team. The same contents built in the calculator cost $598/month billed monthly up to 500 orders, $693.20 at 1,000 and $1,410 at 5,000 (checked Oct 19, 2026).

Current Rebuy pricing

Rokt Aftersell: Aftersell's Shopify App Store listing (live when re-checked Nov 1, 2026) lists a free Development Stores plan, only for development and partner stores, then Post-Purchase at $34.99/month, Pre-Purchase at $59.99 and Complete at $79.99, each with a 30-day free trial and all billed in USD. Its pricing page lists the same starting prices, with Complete 15% less than buying both plans separately. The cards read "for 200 monthly order volume" at the slider's default, but the slider keeps each starting price up to 500 orders, then adds $0.05, $0.03 or $0.07 per order above 500, up to caps of $999.99, $599.99 and $1,359.99 a month. At 20,000 orders the slider switches to "Talk to Sales"; Aftersell Max is custom-priced; Rokt Thanks is free (checked Oct 19, 2026).

Current Rokt Aftersell pricing

Prices checked Oct 19, 2026; Aftersell's listed starting prices re-checked Nov 1, 2026. Different scopes make headline prices misleading: compare only the surfaces you need, then include order volume, package or tier, implementation, and incremental-profit measurement.

Worked example

Monthly cost from 500 to 10,000 orders (editorial calculation)

Availability. Aftersell's Shopify App Store listing is live with an Install button (checked Nov 1, 2026). The listing's prices ($34.99, $59.99 and $79.99 a month) match the starting prices in the Aftersell rows below, which come from its own pricing page.

Assumptions: Shopify store, monthly billing, list prices before taxes, any Shopify Plus offer or thank-you-page earnings. Both columns are what each vendor's pricing-page calculator showed in a browser on Oct 19, 2026. Rebuy prices each package flat up to 500 orders and higher above that, and its calculator shows "Talk to sales" above 7,500 orders. Aftersell's slider keeps each plan's starting price up to 500 orders, then adds a fee for every order above 500 ($0.05 on Post-Purchase, $0.03 on Pre-Purchase, $0.07 on Complete) until the plan's monthly cap, and switches to "Talk to Sales" at 20,000 orders.

Monthly cost, billed monthlyUp to 500 orders/mo1,000 orders/mo5,000 orders/mo10,000 orders/mo
Post-purchase: Rebuy Checkout & Post-Purchase$25$49$225Sales quote
Post-purchase: Aftersell Post-Purchase$34.99$59.99$259.99$509.99
Cart and product page: Rebuy Cart & Merchandising$45$89$425Sales quote
Cart and product page: Aftersell Pre-Purchase$59.99$74.99$194.99$344.99
Both: Rebuy two packages (10% off)$63$124.20$585Sales quote
Both: Aftersell Complete$79.99$114.99$394.99$744.99

Maths: Rebuy's calculator shows Cart & Merchandising at $45, $89 and $425 and Checkout & Post-Purchase at $25, $49 and $225 for up to 500, 1,000 and 5,000 orders; two packages take 10% off, so ($45 + $25) × 0.9 = $63, ($89 + $49) × 0.9 = $124.20 and ($425 + $225) × 0.9 = $585. Aftersell = starting price + per-order fee × (orders − 500): at 5,000 orders, Post-Purchase $34.99 + $0.05 × 4,500 = $259.99, Pre-Purchase $59.99 + $0.03 × 4,500 = $194.99, Complete $79.99 + $0.07 × 4,500 = $394.99; at 10,000, the same fees × 9,500 give $509.99, $344.99 and $744.99. Aftersell marks checkout upsells as Shopify Plus only; Rebuy marks Checkout Extensions as Shopify Plus exclusive. Both pricing pages checked Oct 19, 2026; Aftersell's App Store listing re-checked Nov 1, 2026.

What the numbers show. Which list price is lower depends on the surface and the volume. For post-purchase alone, Rebuy's package lists below Aftersell Post-Purchase at every volume both price: $25 against $34.99 up to 500 orders, $225 against $259.99 at 5,000. For cart and product-page offers, Rebuy is lower up to 500 orders ($45 against $59.99) and Aftersell Pre-Purchase from 1,000 ($74.99 against $89; $194.99 against $425 at 5,000). For both surfaces, Rebuy's pair is lower up to 500 orders ($63 against $79.99) and Aftersell Complete at 1,000 ($114.99 against $124.20) and 5,000 ($394.99 against $585).

Caps and sales quotes. Above 7,500 orders only Aftersell publishes a price. Its caps ($999.99, $599.99 and $1,359.99 a month) only bind from about 18,500 to 19,800 orders, just below the 20,000 orders at which it also moves to sales; at 10,000 orders every Aftersell plan is still below its cap.

What can change it. Both vendors run a free thank-you-page offer product that pays per order: Rebuy Monetize states $0.20 to $0.35+ per transaction and Rokt Thanks $0.30 to $0.80, and Rokt credits those earnings against the Aftersell subscription for eligible stores with over 1,000 orders a month in the US, Canada, Australia or the UK. Payouts depend on shoppers taking offers, so they are left out of the table. Aftersell also advertises free lifetime access to its checkout features ($1,200 annual value, terms apply) for stores recently upgraded to Shopify Plus.

Other options

If Aftersell does not fit

If Aftersell's plans or upsell surfaces do not suit your store, these are the other post-purchase and upsell options BestStorefront covers:

Rebuy Checkout & Post-Purchase covers one-click Post-Purchase Offers, which Rebuy's help center lists without a Shopify Plus requirement, and Checkout Extensions on Shopify Plus, at $25/month up to 500 orders, $49 at 1,000 and $225 at 5,000 (table above). See the Rebuy overview.

Nosto sells a Post-Purchase Upsell module and Dynamic Bundles in its Product Experience Cloud, priced by quote on GMV and traffic, and also runs on BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce, Salesforce Commerce Cloud and Shopware. Compare its pricing model with Rebuy's in Rebuy vs Nosto or read the Nosto overview.

Pre-purchase offers only: if the job is bundles and add-ons on product and cart pages rather than after checkout, the Fast Bundle overview covers bundle products, volume discounts, add-ons and mix-and-match offers on Shopify.

To decide which surface to fund first, use the conversion optimization software guide, and to test offers against a holdout, see Intelligems vs VWO.

Which businesses each one fits

Choose Rebuy if…

  • You need more than post-purchase upsells.
  • Search, merchandising, or cart personalization matters.
  • Order-volume package pricing fits your forecast.

Choose Rokt Aftersell if…

  • Post-purchase and checkout upsells are the main job.
  • A focused app is preferable to a broader personalization layer.
  • The Shopify surfaces you need are available on your plan.

Buyer checklist

What to check in a side-by-side trial

  • Implement an equivalent eligible upsell in both products.
  • Measure page performance, theme compatibility, checkout eligibility, and rollback.
  • Run a predeclared holdout and reconcile orders, refunds, revenue, margin, and customer quality.
  • Audit permissions, exports, analytics, support, and billing at forecast order volumes.

BestStorefront does not name a winner. Run these checks against your own catalog and volumes.

Decision support

Frequently asked questions

Is Aftersell still available on the Shopify App Store?

Yes, as of Nov 1, 2026. Its listing, with Rokt named as developer, showed an Install button and a 4.9 rating from 1,112 reviews when re-checked that day; it was unavailable when BestStorefront checked on Oct 13 and Oct 19, 2026. The listing has a free Development Stores plan for development and partner stores only, plus Post-Purchase, Pre-Purchase and Complete plans, each with a 30-day free trial.

How much does Aftersell cost?

Post-Purchase starts at $34.99/month, Pre-Purchase at $59.99 and Complete at $79.99, each covering up to 500 orders a month on Aftersell's slider. Above 500 orders the fee rises by $0.05, $0.03 or $0.07 per order, so at 1,000 orders the plans cost $59.99, $74.99 and $114.99. Each plan stops at its cap ($999.99, $599.99 and $1,359.99) and has a 30-day free trial (checked Oct 19, 2026). The Shopify App Store listing also has a free Development Stores plan, only for development and partner stores (checked Nov 1, 2026).

How much does Aftersell cost at 5,000 or 10,000 orders a month?

At 5,000 orders: Post-Purchase $259.99 ($34.99 + $0.05 × 4,500), Pre-Purchase $194.99 and Complete $394.99. At 10,000 orders: $509.99, $344.99 and $744.99. No plan reaches its cap below about 18,500 orders, and at 20,000 orders Aftersell's slider switches to Talk to Sales (checked Oct 19, 2026).

How much does Rebuy cost for post-purchase upsells?

Rebuy's Checkout & Post-Purchase package is $25/month up to 500 orders, $49 at 1,000 and $225 at 5,000, billed monthly; annual billing saves 10%. Adding Cart & Merchandising takes the pair to $63, $124.20 or $585 a month at those volumes after the 10% two-package discount. Above 7,500 orders, Rebuy prices through sales (checked Oct 19, 2026).

What can I use instead of Aftersell for post-purchase offers?

Among the tools BestStorefront covers: Rebuy's Checkout & Post-Purchase package for one-click post-purchase offers on Shopify ($25/month up to 500 orders), Nosto's quote-priced Post-Purchase Upsell module for stores on Shopify or other platforms, and Fast Bundle for bundles and add-ons before checkout.

Do I need Shopify Plus for Rebuy or Aftersell?

Only for checkout-page features. Aftersell says checkout upsells are for Shopify Plus merchants only; Rebuy says Checkout Extensions need Shopify Plus plus its Checkout & Post-Purchase package, and Landing Pages are Plus-only. Rebuy's help center lists no Plus requirement for Post-Purchase Offers, and Aftersell flags only checkout upsells; if you are not on Plus, confirm which post-purchase features you can use before you buy (checked Oct 19, 2026).

What are Rebuy Monetize and Rokt Thanks?

Both are free add-ons that show third-party brand offers on the thank-you page and pay the store per order. Rebuy states $0.20 to $0.35+ per transaction; Rokt states $0.30 to $0.80 and credits earnings against the Aftersell bill for eligible stores with over 1,000 monthly orders in the US, Canada, Australia or the UK. These are vendor figures, not guarantees (checked Oct 19, 2026).

Are Rebuy and Rokt Aftersell direct substitutes?

Not in every workflow. Rebuy sells four packages that also cover search, collections and flows; Aftersell's plans center on pre-purchase (cart and product page) and post-purchase (checkout, post-purchase and thank-you page) offers.

Which should I choose?

This comparison does not name a winner. Start with the surfaces required, then compare total cost at your order count and measure incremental profit with a holdout.

Has BestStorefront tested them?

No. This is an editorial overview based on first-party sources, not hands-on testing.

What changed
  • Nov 1, 2026: Corrected the Aftersell availability statements: its Shopify App Store listing, unavailable when we checked on Oct 13 and Oct 19, 2026, was live with an Install button when re-checked Nov 1, 2026. Added the listing's plans (a free Development Stores plan for development and partner stores only; Post-Purchase $34.99, Pre-Purchase $59.99 and Complete $79.99 a month, each with a 30-day free trial), removed the install caveats from the dek, quick answer, worked-example note, Aftersell profile, platform row and FAQs, and renamed the 'If Aftersell is unavailable' section and FAQ. Rebuy's facts were not re-checked.
  • Oct 19, 2026: Re-checked Aftersell's Shopify App Store listing (still unavailable at the time) and both pricing pages, and read both vendors' price calculators in a browser. Replaced the calculator cells with prices at 500, 1,000, 5,000 and 10,000 orders, corrected Aftersell's starting prices to cover up to 500 orders, reconciled the Rebuy Platform One wording, and added an 'If Aftersell is unavailable' section, links to sibling comparisons and FAQs.
  • Oct 13, 2026: Added an availability note: Aftersell's Shopify App Store listing said at the time that the app was not available there. Re-checked Aftersell's plan prices on its pricing page.