Free tool · by BestStorefront
Will your Black Friday discount make money?
The orders a discount needs, rated against your own estimate.See the orders a discount needs to match full-price profit, then rate it against your own order estimate.
Your sale · example numbers
Average, before any discount.
Shopify's Cost per item.
Sitewide, off the regular price.
For context: big US retailers' online discounts peaked at 25.1% (apparel) and 30.9% (electronics) in 2025 (Adobe, Jan 7, 2026, read Nov 14, 2026). Not a target.
Not sure? What if you expect each of these? Each chip says whether that multiple covers the orders 20% off needs (Loses where every sale order loses money). It is not a rating or a forecast. Tap one to use it as your estimate and get a rating:
Left blank, 0 or negative: no Safe or Thin rating, because the tool cannot know your demand. It shows the orders the sale needs instead, and Losing appears only where every sale order loses money. We don't suggest a typical lift: it depends too much on the store. Your last BFCM against a usual week is one way to estimate it.
Work it out from last year
Only scales the dollar answer.
Not rated (no order estimate)
See full resultNeeds 1.85× your usual orders
Orders needed 1.85× · No max safe figure without your estimate
Your other costs per order
Per order, with packaging.
Per order: usage-based apps, inserts, anything else.
Refunds at 0% flatter the result. Use your returns report.
Return shipping, restocking or stock you cannot resell. Counted on your refund rate.
Ad spend ÷ orders. 0 if organic.
Same as usual. Change it if you expect your ad cost to change in the sale.
Example: Shopify Payments, Basic plan, 2.9% + 30¢, from its pricing page, checked Nov 14, 2026 (direct link, not an affiliate link). Replace it with your own rate.
Charged on the discounted price.
More costs: commission, stacked codesCommission and a stacked code.
Paid on the discounted price, reversed on refunds. Counted on every sale order.
For example, an email code that works on sale prices. Leave 0 if codes can't stack.
How the rating is set
- Not rated: you have not entered the orders you expect, and the tool does not guess your demand. It shows the orders the sale needs.
- Losing: shown only where each sale order loses money or earns nothing, because no number of orders fixes that.
- Add the orders you expect to get a Safe, Thin or Losing rating.
Demand is your input; the tool never predicts it.
Every order in the sale gets the full discount, including customers who would have paid full price anyway. Separately, your costs stay the same when the price drops, so each point off takes a bigger share of profit and the orders needed climb faster than the discount. Not modelled: fixed overhead and labor, leftover inventory, orders pulled forward from later weeks, repeat purchases after the sale, and how many extra orders the discount brings (that number is yours to enter).
Discount ladder
What each discount does to your profit
Every point off comes out of your profit, not your costs, so the extra orders you need climb faster than the discount does. Profit here is per order, before overhead and labor. You have not entered the orders you expect, so no row is rated. A row says Losing only where every order loses money.
| OffDiscount | PriceSale price | ProfitProfit per order before overhead and labor | OrdersOrders needed | RatingVerdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | $54.00 | $19.63 | 1.30× | Not ratedNot rated |
| 20%your plan | $48.00 | $13.81 | 1.85× | Not ratedNot rated |
| 30% | $42.00 | $7.98 | 3.19× | Not ratedNot rated |
| 40% | $36.00 | $2.16 | over 10× | Not ratedNot rated |
| 50% | $30.00 | -$3.67 | No lift is enough | LosingLosing vs full price |
Profit is per order, before overhead and labor. Orders is how many times your usual orders the discount needs. No Safe or Thin rating without your order estimate. A row says Losing only where every sale order loses money.
What to do next
Sharpen the numbers behind your verdict
- Work out your ad cost per order
The MER & CAC calculator turns ad spend and orders into the cost per order this check needs.
- Check your real payment fee
Model your processor's rate, international cards and monthly fees.
- Read how payment fees add up
Published US card rates and what changes them, with sources.
- Browse conversion and checkout tools
A guide to software that lifts order value, with a few upsell and bundle apps among them.
Next step
Check your numbers against real payments pricing
Payment fees come out of every discounted order. If you're comparing processors, each figure below links to the page that states it and shows the date we read it. Listed alphabetically, not ranked. Each overview is based on first-party sources, not hands-on testing.
None of these links is an affiliate link.
- Official siteAdyen overview · A fixed processing fee plus a payment-method fee on each transaction (source page, checked Nov 16, 2026)
- Official sitePayPal overview · Price: not yet verified
- Official siteSquare overview · Online 3.3% + 30¢ on the first plan, 2.9% + 30¢ on the others; Online API (developer integration) 2.9% + 30¢ (source page, checked Nov 16, 2026)
- Official siteStripe overview · 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card payment (source page, checked Nov 14, 2026)
See the payments desk for the full buying framework.
How this tool works
Black Friday discount check: method, assumptions and an example
A sale discount pays only if the extra orders cover the profit it takes off each order. The tool shows profit per order before and after the discount (before overhead and labor), how many times your normal orders the sale needs to match full-price profit, the discount past which every order loses money, break-even ROAS and a chart of every discount from 10 to 50%. It gives a Safe or Thin rating only against the orders you expect, an estimate you enter yourself. With no estimate it shows the orders needed, says plainly that nothing is rated and gives no max safe discount; it still says Losing where every sale order loses money, because that needs no estimate. With an estimate it also gives the profit change in dollars over your usual orders.
Inputs
- Regular price per order, cost of goods and the shipping and packaging you pay.
- Your other costs per order, shown up front: payment fee (a preset, or percentage and fixed), apps or other cost per order, and ad cost per order at full price and during the sale.
- The planned discount, the refund rate and the cost per return (the return label and handling you pay).
- Orders you expect: the order multiple (for example 1.6×), which is optional but is the only thing a Safe or Thin rating rests on, and how many orders you usually get, so the result can show profit in dollars.
- Under More costs: affiliate or creator commission, and a stacking code.
Method
- Sale price = regular price × (1 − discount) × (1 − stacked code).
- Profit per order = kept revenue − commission − payment fees − cost of goods kept − shipping − apps − ad cost − refund rate × cost per return, where kept = 1 − refund rate.
- Orders needed = profit per order at full price ÷ profit per order in the sale, rounded up to 0.01×; anything above 10× reads "over 10×".
- Profit change = usual orders × expected multiple × profit per sale order, minus usual orders × profit per full-price order.
- Rating, only with your estimate: Safe if your expected multiple beats the orders needed by at least 20%, Thin if it covers them with less cushion, Losing if it falls short. With no estimate nothing is rated. Losing still appears where every sale order loses money, because no number of orders fixes that.
- Max safe discount = the deepest discount that still meets the Safe rule at your estimate. There is no figure without an estimate. The break-even discount, where profit per order reaches $0, needs no estimate.
- Most ad cost a sale order can carry = profit per sale order + ad cost per sale order; break-even ROAS = sale price ÷ that amount; margin after ads = profit per sale order ÷ sale price.
Assumptions
- Profit here is what is left of each order after goods, shipping, payment fees, apps, ads, commission, refunds and return costs, before overhead and labor.
- Every order in the sale gets the full discount, including customers who would have paid full price anyway. Separately, your costs stay the same when the price drops, so each point off takes a bigger share of profit and the orders needed climb faster than the discount.
- Refunds return the sale price and restock the item; shipping, payment fees, app and ad costs are not recovered and commission is reversed. Commission and a stacked code are counted on every sale order.
- The 20% cushion is BestStorefront's own rule of thumb, not an industry benchmark, applied to your estimate. A rating is only as good as that estimate: change the estimate and the rating changes.
Limitations
- It never predicts how many extra orders a discount brings; that number is yours to enter, and without it nothing is rated.
- Not modelled: fixed overhead and labor, leftover inventory, orders pulled forward from later weeks, repeat purchases after the sale, and how many extra orders the discount brings (that number is yours to enter).
Worked example
Illustrative inputs: a $100 order with $40 cost of goods and no other costs, at 30% off. Profit figures are before overhead and labor.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Profit per order at full price: $100 − $40 | $60.00 |
| Profit per order at 30% off: $70 − $40 | $30.00 |
| Orders needed: $60 ÷ $30 | 2.00× |
| Every order loses money past | 60% off |
| Rating with no order estimate | Not rated (needs 2.00×) |
| Rating if you expect 1.5× orders | Losing vs full price |
| Rating if you expect 2.4× orders | Safe vs full price |
| Profit on 100 usual orders at full price: 100 × $60 | $6,000 |
| Profit on 100 usual orders at 1.5×, 30% off: 150 × $30 | $4,500 (so $1,500 less profit) |
A 30% discount halves profit per order here, so the sale needs twice the normal orders just to stand still. Whether that is Safe, Thin or Losing depends on the orders you expect: at 1.5× it makes $1,500 less profit than full price over 100 usual orders, and with no estimate it is not rated at all. At 40% off it would need 3×.
How to read the result
- Read the ladder before picking a number: the orders you need climb faster than the discount.
- Treat a rating as only as good as your estimate of the orders you expect. Try a few values and watch where the rating changes.
- If your sale ad cost per order rises, enter it; it can move the result as much as the discount does.
Questions
- How much should I discount for Black Friday?
- Only as deep as your profit per order and your own order estimate allow. Enter your own costs and the orders you expect: the max safe discount is the deepest discount your estimate covers with a 20% cushion, so it depends on that estimate and there is no figure without one. With no estimate the tool still shows the orders each discount needs and the discount past which every order loses money.
- How many more orders does a discount need to match full-price profit?
- Divide profit per order at full price by profit per order in the sale. With a $100 price and $40 cost of goods, 30% off cuts profit from $60 to $30, so you need 2× your normal orders. Profit here is before overhead and labor.
- Why does a bigger discount need so many more orders?
- Every point of discount comes out of profit, not cost: your costs stay the same when the price drops, so profit per order falls faster than the price. Separately, every order in the sale gets the discount, including customers who would have paid full price anyway. In the $100 example, 30% off halves profit per order and needs 2× orders, while 40% off leaves $20 of profit and needs 3×. The ladder shows this for your own numbers.
- Why is there no Safe or Thin rating when I leave the orders I expect blank?
- A rating only means something against the orders you expect, and the tool does not guess your demand. Without that estimate it shows the orders the sale needs and what is unknown. It still says Losing where every sale order loses money, because no number of extra orders fixes that.
- Does the tool count customers who would have paid full price anyway?
- Yes. It assumes every order in the sale gets the full discount, including those customers. Separately, your costs stay the same when the price drops, so each point off takes a bigger share of profit and the orders needed climb faster than the discount. What it does not model is orders pulled forward from later weeks or repeat purchases after the sale.
- What does "before overhead and labor" mean?
- Profit per order here is what is left after goods, shipping, payment fees, apps, ads, commission, refunds and return costs. Rent, salaries, your own time and other fixed costs are not taken out, so it is not your business profit.
- What break-even ROAS does my sale need?
- Sale price divided by the most ad cost a sale order can carry (profit per sale order plus the ad cost you entered). Below that ROAS each ad-driven sale order loses money. The tool shows it for your own costs on the Ads line under the three result tiles, next to the max ad cost per order. Your margin after ads is in How this was worked out.
- How do I estimate my order lift?
- Use the Work it out from last year helper under the expected orders field. Enter how many orders you got in a past sale and in a usual period of the same length, and press Use. It divides one by the other, so 300 orders in the sale and 120 in a usual period gives 2.5×. It is your own history, not a forecast; a quick sale with no past data is a guess, so try a few values and watch where the rating changes.
- Does it work for sales other than Black Friday?
- Yes. The math is the same for any promotion: a sitewide sale, a launch code or a stacked email code. Enter the ad cost per order you expect during that sale and, if you have one, the order multiple you expect.
- What does it leave out?
- Fixed overhead and labor, leftover inventory, orders pulled forward from later weeks and repeat purchases after the sale. It also never predicts how many extra orders a discount brings: that number is yours to enter, and the rating and the dollar answer are only as good as that estimate.
Your inputs stay in your browser. Our analytics record only that a tool was started, completed or shared, and the page address without your figures. A result link you copy does carry your numbers, so share it only where you're happy for them to be seen.