Quick answer
- Reviews at the lowest cost: Judge.me: free, or $15/month flat. Shopify only.
- Reviews and loyalty from one Shopify-focused vendor: Okendo, reviews from $19/month, with a separate loyalty product.
- Reviews plus a separate loyalty product, across more platforms: Yotpo.
- Photo and video reviews: Loox.
- Already on Klaviyo: Klaviyo Reviews, priced by monthly orders.
- Stay on Stamped if you want reviews and loyalty from one vendor on its Shopify plans and its order tiers suit you.
Worked example
Review costs at two order volumes
The plan each app needs to send review requests at 500 and 3,000 orders a month, at list prices. Loyalty products are priced separately.
| App (plan needed) | 500 orders/month | 3,000 orders/month |
|---|---|---|
| Judge.me | $0 Free or $15 Awesome (flat) | $0 Free or $15 Awesome (flat) |
| Yotpo Reviews | $89 Starter (up to 500 orders) | $329 Pro (Starter stops at 1,000 orders) |
| Loox | $99.99 Convert ($49.99 + one $50 block of 300 orders) | $299.99 Unlimited (Convert would be $49.99 + 9 × $50 = $499.99) |
| Okendo | $119 Growth (up to 1,500 orders) | $299 Power (up to 3,500 orders) |
| Stamped (Shopify plans) | $99 Reviews 1k (up to 1,000 orders) | $199 Reviews 5k (up to 5,000 orders) |
| Klaviyo Reviews | $90 (up to 1,000 orders) | $300 (up to 3,500 orders) |
Editorial calculation, Oct 7, 2026. Stamped figures are its Shopify App Store plans; its direct plans start at $199/month per product. Yotpo figures come from its website's order-volume slider.
Compare all review apps on the Reviews & UGC desk.
Baseline
Stamped baseline (for comparison)
Stamped's Shopify App Store plans: Reviews $23/month (up to 200 orders), $99 (1,000 orders) and $199 (5,000 orders); Loyalty $299 (5,000 orders), billed every 30 days in USD. Its own pricing page lists direct plans from $199/month for a single product and $798/month for multi-product access, with extra domains at $100/month. Full overview: Stamped review.
Not ranked
The 5 alternatives
Not ranked. All five have full BestStorefront overviews.
Judge.me — free or $15 flat
- Best for
- Shopify stores that want full-featured reviews at the lowest cost.
- Pricing (verified Oct 7, 2026)
- Forever Free with unlimited review requests; Awesome $15/month flat at any order volume; 15-day trial.
- Watch out for
- Shopify only since early 2026, and no loyalty product.
- Read more
- Judge.me overview
Okendo — reviews, UGC and loyalty for Shopify
- Best for
- Growing Shopify brands that want reviews and loyalty from one Shopify-focused vendor.
- Pricing (verified Oct 7, 2026)
- Reviews: free to 50 orders; Essential $19 (200 orders), Growth $119 (1,500), Power $299 (3,500). Loyalty is priced separately.
- Watch out for
- Order-based pricing steps up quickly with growth; Shopify only.
- Read more
- Okendo overview
Yotpo — reviews and loyalty across platforms
- Best for
- Brands on Adobe Commerce, BigCommerce or Salesforce Commerce Cloud, or those wanting Yotpo's separate loyalty product.
- Pricing (verified Oct 7, 2026)
- Reviews free to 50 orders; Starter $89 at 500 orders and Pro $329 at 3,000 in our check. Loyalty from free to Pro at $199/month (500 orders).
- Watch out for
- Its Shopify listing shows lower entry prices than the website's volume-based prices.
- Compare
- Yotpo alternatives
Loox — photo and video reviews
- Best for
- Visual brands where photo and video reviews drive conversion.
- Pricing (verified Oct 7, 2026)
- Beginner free (500 orders); Convert $49.99 for 300 orders plus $50 per extra 300; Unlimited $299.99.
- Watch out for
- No loyalty product; Shopify only.
- Read more
- Loox overview
Klaviyo Reviews — reviews inside Klaviyo
- Best for
- Stores already on Klaviyo that want review requests next to email and SMS.
- Pricing (verified Oct 7, 2026)
- Free to 50 orders, then $25 (250), $90 (1,000), $175 (2,000), $300 (3,500) per month.
- Watch out for
- Requires Klaviyo; Shopify and WooCommerce only, per Klaviyo's help center.
- Read more
- Klaviyo pricing
Switching costs
When to stay on Stamped
- You use Stamped's reviews and loyalty together and want one vendor and one bill.
- Your order volume sits comfortably inside a Shopify plan tier.
- Your review widgets and syndication are configured and working.
Before switching, export your reviews and confirm the new app imports photos, dates and verification labels.
Decision support
Frequently asked questions
How much does Stamped cost?
On the Shopify App Store, Reviews starts at $23/month for up to 200 orders, rising to $99 and $199; Loyalty is $299 at 5,000 orders. Stamped's own site lists direct plans from $199/month per product.
What is the cheapest alternative to Stamped?
Judge.me: free with unlimited review requests, or $15/month flat for its paid plan.
Which alternatives also offer loyalty?
Okendo and Yotpo both sell loyalty products alongside reviews, priced separately.
Has BestStorefront tested these apps?
No. This page is an independent editorial overview based on each vendor's published pricing; hands-on testing is pending.
Documentation